TL;DR
Get baking supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Stewart’s Shops Corp. is recalling its Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry half-gallon ice creams because they may contain metal. The products were sold at Stewart’s Shops in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire from July 17 through Oct. 2, 2026; no injuries or illnesses had been reported in the recall announcement.
Stewart’s Shops Corp. is recalling its Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry half-gallon ice creams because of the possible presence of metal, according to a company announcement posted by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration on Oct. 2. The products were sold at Stewart’s Shops locations in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire; the company said no injuries or illnesses had been reported at the time of the announcement.
The recall applies to one-half-gallon paperboard cartons of both flavors, sold between July 17 and Oct. 2, 2026. The Heavenly Medley cartons have a best-by date of Feb. 10, 2027, and UPC 0 82086 44371 1. Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry cartons have a best-by date of Feb. 11, 2027, and UPC 0 82086 44377 3. The announcement lists all products of each flavor as covered; it does not specify a narrower lot or batch code.
Stewart’s said it began the recall after a consumer found a metal object in a half-gallon carton. The announcement does not identify the object, describe how it may have entered the product, or say whether other cartons were tested. The FDA’s notice identifies the reason as the potential presence of metal and says the agency posted the company’s announcement as a public service; it does not characterize the posting as an FDA endorsement.
Consumers who bought either recalled flavor are advised not to eat the ice cream. The company says customers can return cartons to any Stewart’s Shops location for a full refund. The products are ready-to-eat frozen ice cream intended for home consumption, and the announcement gives no additional preparation or handling steps.
What Consumers Should Do With Cartons
The recall concerns a possible physical contamination hazard in a food product intended to be eaten without further cooking. Metal in ice cream could pose a risk of injury if swallowed, though the announcement does not report any injuries or illnesses connected with these products. That absence of reports is the status given at the time of the notice, not a guarantee that no exposure occurred.
Checking the flavor, package size, best-by date and UPC can help shoppers identify whether a carton matches the recall. Because the company says all products of both listed flavors are included, consumers should not rely on finding a particular lot number before taking action. Returning the product for a refund is the company’s stated remedy; consumers should not eat it while seeking more information.
The stated sales window covers more than two months and three states, so the notice may affect customers who bought the ice cream well before the announcement. Anyone who has a carton but is unsure whether it matches the listed details can contact Stewart’s using the information in the company notice.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Recall Scope and Product Details
The recall was announced by Stewart’s Shops Corp., based in Saratoga Springs, New York. Its notice says the two products were sold only through Stewart’s Shops locations in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire during the specified sales period. The products are described as frozen, ready-to-eat ice cream in paperboard cartons, each holding one-half gallon, or 1.89 liters.
The FDA page labels the notice a company announcement. It explains that when a company announces a recall, market withdrawal or safety alert, the agency posts the announcement as a public service and does not endorse the company or its products. The notice gives Oct. 2, 2026, as both the company announcement date and the FDA publication date.
The two affected products are identified by flavor, best-by date and UPC. Heavenly Medley is listed with a Feb. 10, 2027, best-by date; Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry is listed with a Feb. 11, 2027, date. The company’s notice does not provide a separate production date, manufacturing facility, or specific batch codes that would further narrow the recall.
““The recall was initiated after a metal object was discovered by a consumer in a half-gallon carton of ice cream.””
— Stewart’s Shops Corp., in its recall announcement
What the Notice Does Not Explain
The announcement does not say what kind of metal object was found, how large it was, or whether it was found in one carton or more than one. It also does not explain the source of the potential contamination, the production circumstances, or what steps the company has taken to prevent a recurrence. Those details are not specified in the posted notice.
The company says no injuries or illnesses had been reported when it announced the recall, but the notice does not provide a consumer exposure count or state whether any complaints were still being assessed. It is also unclear whether the company or FDA will issue additional findings, and the announcement does not give a timeline for further updates.
The recall notice does not list a separate lot or batch code. It instead identifies the affected products by flavor and supplies the best-by dates and UPCs. Customers should use the listed product information and the company’s instruction not to consume either flavor, rather than assume an unlisted batch distinction excludes a carton.
Refunds and Recall Updates
Customers with either recalled flavor can return the carton to any Stewart’s Shops location for a full refund, according to the company. People seeking clarification can contact Stewart’s consumer and media representative, Robin Cooper, at 518-248-0455 or rcooper@stewartsshops.com. The notice does not provide a separate deadline for returns.
Further information may come from Stewart’s or the FDA if the company updates its announcement or the agency posts additional material. As of the Oct. 2 notice, the confirmed public guidance is to avoid consuming the affected products and return them to a Stewart’s location. No later investigation results or additional recall actions are provided in the source announcement.
Key Questions
Which Stewart’s Shops ice creams are included in the recall?
The recall covers Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry in one-half-gallon paperboard cartons. The listed best-by dates are Feb. 10, 2027, and Feb. 11, 2027, respectively; the notice also provides a UPC for each flavor.
Where and when were the recalled products sold?
Stewart’s says the ice creams were sold at its shops in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire from July 17 through Oct. 2, 2026.
Why were the ice creams recalled?
The company recalled the products because of the possible presence of metal. Stewart’s said the recall followed a consumer’s discovery of a metal object in one half-gallon carton. The notice does not describe the object or explain how it entered the product.
What should I do if I have one of the recalled cartons?
Do not eat it. Stewart’s says customers can return either product to any Stewart’s Shops location for a full refund. For questions, contact the company at 518-248-0455 or rcooper@stewartsshops.com.
Have any injuries or illnesses been reported?
Stewart’s said no injuries or illnesses had been reported in connection with the problem when it issued the Oct. 2, 2026, announcement. The notice does not include later updates.
Source: primary
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
