If you’re searching for a fridge ice maker, you’re likely looking for a reliable way to keep your ice supply steady without hassle. The best overall pick, the Frigidaire Countertop Portable Ice Maker, offers impressive capacity and portability, making it ideal for most households. Meanwhile, the Antarctic Star countertop model excels with its fast ice production and compact size, perfect for quick needs. Some options focus on replacements for built-in units, which can be more affordable but may require more installation effort. As you explore your choices, you’ll weigh factors like capacity, size, ease of use, and compatibility. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of the best options and what to consider before buying.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The best ice makers balance high capacity with compact design, catering to different kitchen and space needs.
- Countertop models often offer portability and faster ice production, but built-in replacements provide a seamless look.
- Price varies significantly—premium options tend to provide greater durability and advanced features, while budget picks focus on basic functionality.
- Ease of installation and maintenance are common tradeoffs—more complex setups may save space but require more effort.
- Compatibility with your refrigerator or countertop space should guide your final choice, especially for replacements.
| Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker Machine, 26Lbs/Day, Fast 6-Minute Ice |  | Best Overall for Portable, Fast Ice Production | Ice Production Capacity: 26 lbs per day | Ice Type: Bullet ice | Preparation Time: 6 minutes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 241798224 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Frigidaire and Kenmore |  | Best Value for Quick Replacement in Compatible Models | Model Name: 241798224 | Item Count: 1 | Brand: Nurfosttek | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kitchen Basics 101 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore, Sears Refrigerators |  | Best for Fixed, Reliable Ice Production in Specific Models | Model Number: 241798224 / 241642511 | Dimensions: 4.5 x 4.75 x 11.3 inches | Unit Count: 8 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ice Maker Replacement Compatible with Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore Refrigerators |  | Best for Wide Compatibility and DIY Fixes | Compatible Brands: Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore | Features: Built-in wiring harness, easy DIY installation | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown | |
| Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black |  | Best Compact Countertop for Daily Ice Needs | Rated Power: 105W | Refrigerant: R600a | Dimensions: 13 x 11 x 12.5 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ice Maker Replacement 241798231 241798224 241798211, Compatible with Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore Refrigerators |  | Best for Budget-Friendly Repairs | Model Numbers: 241798224, 241798231, 241798211, 241642511 | Replacement Part Numbers: 241798224, 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951, 5304456672, 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12085911, 3206327, 3206329 | Brand: AYISMAK | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators |  | Best for DIY Enthusiasts with Compatibility Confidence | Part Number: 241798231 | Color: White | Compatibility: Refrigerators (verify with user manual) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Countertop Portable Ice Maker, 26 lbs per Day, Black Stainless Steel |  | Best for Small Spaces and Quick Ice on Demand | Ice Production: 26 lbs per day | Ice Cube Size: Two options | Water Capacity: 2.1 qt. | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine, Bullet Ice, 26 lb per Day |  | Best for Stylish Retro Design and Easy Monitoring | Capacity: 26 lbs per day | Ice Cube Size: Two sizes | Reservoir Capacity: 2.2 lbs | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact Ice Maker, Stainless Steel |  | Best for Continuous Ice Production and User Convenience | Brand: Frigidaire | Model: EFIC117-SS | Unit Count: 1 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Antarctic Star Countertop Ice Maker Machine, 26Lbs/Day, Fast 6-Minute Ice
This compact ice maker stands out for delivering ice in just 6 minutes, making it ideal for parties and outdoor gatherings where quick replenishment is needed. Compared with the Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK, it offers faster cycle times, though it sacrifices some storage capacity since it produces ice on demand rather than storing it. Its energy efficiency and quiet operation make it suitable for indoor use without disturbance. The self-cleaning feature adds convenience, but it requires regular maintenance to keep performance optimal. Its small size allows easy placement in limited spaces, yet it’s limited to countertop use, so it can’t replace built-in models.
Pros:- Fast ice production in just 6 minutes
- Energy-efficient with 30% lower consumption
- Compact and portable for various settings
- Quiet operation for undisturbed use
Cons:- Limited to countertop placement
- Requires regular cleaning for optimal performance
Best for: People hosting frequent gatherings who need quick, portable ice solutions.
Not ideal for: Large households requiring continuous ice supply or built-in systems, due to its limited capacity and portability.
- Ice Production Capacity:26 lbs per day
- Ice Type:Bullet ice
- Preparation Time:6 minutes
- Dimensions:8.74″ x 11.47″ x 11.57″
- Noise Level:<40dB
- Energy Consumption:30% less
Our verdict“This pick is perfect for users who need quick, portable ice on demand, especially during parties or outdoor events.”
241798224 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Frigidaire and Kenmore
This replacement part excels at restoring ice functionality quickly, especially compared to waiting for a full new unit like the Kitchen Basics 101. It’s compatible with many Frigidaire and Kenmore models, making it a versatile choice for those looking to fix their existing refrigerator’s ice maker without upgrading. The adjustable ice size feature helps customize output, and its food-grade construction ensures safety. Installation is straightforward with a simple four-step DIY process, but it requires careful model verification beforehand. Some users report noise or fit issues, which can be a concern if not carefully checked.
Pros:- Broad compatibility with various models
- Quick ice-making recovery
- Adjustable ice size
- Easy DIY installation
Cons:- Requires careful model compatibility check
- Some users experience noise or fit issues
Best for: Homeowners seeking a cost-effective, quick fix for their refrigerator’s ice maker system.
Not ideal for: Buyers without compatible models or those uncomfortable with DIY repairs, as incorrect fit can lead to ongoing issues.
- Model Name:241798224
- Item Count:1
- Brand:Nurfosttek
- Part Number:241798224
- Customer Reviews:4.0/5
- Best Sellers Rank:#58,138 in Tools & Home Improvement, #33 in Refrigerator Replacement Ice Makers
Our verdict“This replacement is best suited for those who want a fast, affordable fix for their refrigerator’s ice maker, provided compatibility is confirmed.”
Kitchen Basics 101 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore, Sears Refrigerators
This replacement offers a simple, reliable solution for maintaining ice production in select refrigerators, producing 8 ice cubes per cycle with an automatic shut-off arm. Compared to larger capacity units like the Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK, it’s more limited in output but excels in fitting easily into existing models. Its 1-year warranty provides peace of mind, though installation may require some technical skill, making it less suited for those uncomfortable with repairs. It’s a straightforward choice for homeowners with compatible models needing a direct replacement.
Pros:- Easy to install in compatible models
- Produces 8 ice cubes per cycle efficiently
- Includes a 1-year warranty
- Automatic shut-off for safety
Cons:- Limited to specific models
- May require technical installation skills
- No detailed user feedback available
Best for: Owners of specific Electrolux, Frigidaire, or Kenmore refrigerators needing a straightforward, reliable fix.
Not ideal for: Users with incompatible models or those seeking high-capacity or portable solutions, as this is a fixed, lower-output replacement.
- Model Number:241798224 / 241642511
- Dimensions:4.5 x 4.75 x 11.3 inches
- Unit Count:8
- UPC:816325011719
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This replacement is ideal for owners of compatible refrigerators seeking a straightforward, dependable ice maker upgrade.”
Ice Maker Replacement Compatible with Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore Refrigerators
This versatile replacement helps solve common ice maker issues like no ice production or noise, especially compared to models like Kitchen Basics 101 that focus on specific brands. Its built-in wiring harness simplifies installation, but it’s not a universal fit—compatibility must be verified beforehand. For those comfortable with technical work, it offers a flexible solution across many brands, reducing the need to replace entire refrigerators. However, incorrect matching or installation challenges could lead to continued problems, so careful compatibility checks are essential.
Pros:- Compatible with multiple brands
- Easy to install with wired harness
- Helps resolve common issues like noise and failure to turn off
- Reduces need for full replacement
Cons:- Not universal—must check compatibility
- Installation may require some technical skill
- Compatibility issues may persist if not verified accurately
Best for: DIY homeowners needing a flexible, broadly compatible fix for multiple refrigerator brands.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking plug-and-play solutions without technical skill, or with models not listed in compatibility info.
- Compatible Brands:Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore
- Features:Built-in wiring harness, easy DIY installation
Our verdict“This replacement suits tech-savvy users aiming for a flexible repair option across various refrigerator models.”
Frigidaire EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Black
This Frigidaire model offers a reliable, countertop solution with a 26-pound daily capacity, comparable to the Antarctic Star. Its large transparent window allows monitoring of ice levels, and its 5-6 minute cycle time ensures quick output. Unlike units that only produce ice, it does not store it, requiring prompt transfer to a freezer to prevent melting. Its sleek design fits well in small kitchens or offices, but the lack of storage means it’s less suited for continuous use without constant attention. It’s a solid pick for those who want portable, daily-use ice without integrating into their existing fridge system.
Pros:- Compact and portable design
- Fast cycle time of 5-6 minutes
- Large transparent window for monitoring
- Produces 26 pounds daily
Cons:- Does not store ice, only produces it
- Requires quick transfer to freezer to prevent melting
- Limited to countertop use
Best for: Small households or office spaces needing quick, portable ice without built-in freezer integration.
Not ideal for: Large families or those wanting continuous ice supply without frequent transfer, due to no storage capability.
- Rated Power:105W
- Refrigerant:R600a
- Dimensions:13 x 11 x 12.5 inches
- Ice Production:26 lbs per day
- Cycle Time:5-6 minutes
- Ice Cubes per Cycle:9
Our verdict“This pick is perfect for users seeking portable, rapid ice production in small spaces, with the understanding it won’t store ice long-term.”
Ice Maker Replacement 241798231 241798224 241798211, Compatible with Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore Refrigerators
This replacement ice maker from AYISMAK stands out for offering an affordable, straightforward fix for common ice production issues in compatible refrigerators like Electrolux and Kenmore. Compared with the Frigidaire 241798231 Assembly Kit, it provides a quick, plug-and-play solution that addresses noise and failure without needing specialized tools. However, this model’s compatibility is limited to specific refrigerator models, and its durability remains uncertain, making it less ideal for long-term replacements.
Best for homeowners seeking an easy repair who want a quick fix without replacing the entire unit. Not ideal for those looking for a durable, long-lasting part since lifespan info isn’t specified.
Pros:- Simple installation with a built-in wiring box
- Compatible with multiple refrigerator models
- Addresses common issues like noise and failure
Cons:- Compatibility limited to specific models
- Uncertain durability and lifespan
Best for: Homeowners needing an affordable, easy-to-install replacement for compatible fridge models
Not ideal for: Users seeking a long-term, durable solution for frequent ice maker failures
- Model Numbers:241798224, 241798231, 241798211, 241642511
- Replacement Part Numbers:241798224, 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951, 5304456672, 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12085911, 3206327, 3206329
- Brand:AYISMAK
- Item Count:1
- Part Number:241798231 / 241798224
- Rank:#100,326 in Tools & Home Improvement
- Customer Rating:5/5
Our verdict“A practical choice for budget-conscious homeowners who need a quick replacement for compatible refrigerators.”
Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators
This genuine Frigidaire assembly kit offers peace of mind through its perfect compatibility and high-quality build, making it ideal for experienced DIYers confident in verifying model compatibility. Compared with the generic replacement from AYISMAK, this kit ensures dependable ice production with a straightforward installation process. Its main limitation lies in requiring specific tools and verification against your refrigerator’s model, so it’s less suited for casual users or those with uncertain compatibility.
This pick makes the most sense for DIYers who want a guaranteed fit and reliable performance but should be avoided by those unfamiliar with appliance repair or lacking the necessary tools.
Pros:- Genuine Frigidaire part guarantees compatibility
- Ensures reliable ice production
- Designed for straightforward DIY installation
Cons:- Requires specific tools and experience
- Compatibility must be verified with your model
Best for: DIY homeowners with compatible Frigidaire refrigerators seeking a reliable, OEM replacement
Not ideal for: Users without DIY skills or those unsure about model compatibility
- Part Number:241798231
- Color:White
- Compatibility:Refrigerators (verify with user manual)
Our verdict“Ideal for experienced DIYers who want a guaranteed quality replacement for their Frigidaire fridge.”
Frigidaire Countertop Portable Ice Maker, 26 lbs per Day, Black Stainless Steel
This compact, stylish ice maker produces up to 26 pounds of bullet-shaped ice daily, making it a strong choice for entertaining, offices, or small kitchens. It surpasses larger built-in units in portability and ease of use, thanks to its digital control panel and large water capacity. The main tradeoff is its limited ice storage—just 1.5 pounds—meaning frequent emptying or transfer is necessary to prevent melting. It can also be noisy, which might bother some users during operation.
This makes the most sense for users who want quick, reliable ice without installing a permanent fixture but isn’t ideal for those who need to store large amounts of ice continuously.
Pros:- Fast production: 9 cubes every 7 minutes
- Sleek stainless steel design
- Digital control panel for easy operation
- Large water tank reduces refill frequency
Cons:- Limited ice storage capacity
- Can be noisy during operation
- Requires regular cleaning to prevent buildup
Best for: Small households, office spaces, or parties where portable and fast ice is needed
Not ideal for: Users needing large, continuous ice storage or silent operation
- Ice Production:26 lbs per day
- Ice Cube Size:Two options
- Water Capacity:2.1 qt.
- Ice Basket Capacity:1.5 lbs
- Material:Black stainless steel
- Production Time:9 cubes every 7 minutes
Our verdict“A practical, stylish choice for those who need quick ice in small volumes and value portability.”
Frigidaire Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine, Bullet Ice, 26 lb per Day
This retro-style ice maker offers a generous 26 pounds of ice daily with a charming stainless steel appearance and a transparent window for easy monitoring. It’s a good fit for those who want a high-capacity portable device with a modern twist. Unlike countertop units that only produce ice, this model doesn’t store ice, requiring users to transfer ice to a freezer to prevent melting, which can be inconvenient during long events. Its quick production time—less than 6 minutes—is a plus for fast-paced use.
This product is ideal for style-conscious users who don’t mind transferring ice, but not for those needing continuous ice storage.
Pros:- High daily ice capacity of 26 lbs
- Stylish retro design with transparent window
- Fast production: less than 6 minutes
- Easy electronic controls
Cons:- No ice storage—requires transfer to freezer
- Limited to portable use only
- Needs manual transfer to prevent melting
Best for: Stylish, high-capacity portable ice makers for short-term use at parties or events
Not ideal for: Users who want to store ice long-term or don’t want to transfer ice to a freezer
- Capacity:26 lbs per day
- Ice Cube Size:Two sizes
- Reservoir Capacity:2.2 lbs
- Material:Stainless Steel
- Production Time:Less than 6 minutes
Our verdict“Best suited for users who prioritize style and quick ice production over long-term storage needs.”
Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact Ice Maker, Stainless Steel
This sleek Frigidaire EFIC117-SS produces up to 26 pounds of ice daily with fast output—9 cubes every 7 minutes—making it ideal for busy households or gatherings. Its large water tank and digital LED controls simplify operation, and the stainless steel finish matches modern kitchens. Compared with the Retro model, this unit provides a slightly larger storage capacity of 1.5 pounds, ensuring less frequent refills. However, it still requires regular water top-offs and can generate some noise, which might be a concern in quiet environments.
This model is best for users who want a reliable, easy-to-use portable ice maker for frequent use but may not suit those who need silent operation or extensive ice storage.
Pros:- Produces 26 lbs of ice daily
- Fast ice output: 9 cubes every 7 minutes
- Large water tank for continuous use
- Modern stainless steel design
Cons:- Limited ice storage capacity
- Requires regular water refills
- Some noise during operation
Best for: Active households or small businesses needing consistent, on-demand ice
Not ideal for: Those seeking silent operation or large, long-term ice storage
- Brand:Frigidaire
- Model:EFIC117-SS
- Unit Count:1
- Manufacturer:Curtis
- Warranty:1 year
- Ice Production Capacity:26 lbs per day
- Water Tank Capacity:2.1 qt
- Included Components:Ice maker, ice scoop
Our verdict“A solid choice for users who need dependable, quick ice with modern convenience features.”
